After the 2024 Softball season concluded, coaches from the Lancaster Lebanon League and the Mid Penn Conference voted on which players they thought deserved All-Star status. Among the players selected were TWENTY-SIX athletes from LebCo’s six high school teams. FIFTEEN talented young ladies brought home First Team selections in their respective leagues/divisions.
Annville-Cleona, ELCO, and Northern Lebanon led the way with all-star selections, each with six. Of those given honors, the Dutchmen and Vikings received five First Team nods.
Something to note here is that only six of the twenty-six selections were seniors. While those seniors each led their teams, the returning talent should bode well for our local squads in 2025.
Below is a breakdown of all the selected players, categorized in three different ways to suit your reading preference.
If you like this type of coverage, please let us know by Following us on social media: Twitter/X – @lebcosports1 and Facebook.
For any questions, comments, or discrepancies, please reach out to dan@lebcosports.com.
Full List – Alphabetical
Brooke Beamesderfer, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Temperence Brubaker, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Anna Crawford, Palmyra: 3rd Team – Mid Penn Keystone Division
Kenzie Deeks, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Abby Hassler, ELCO: Honorable Mention – LL Section 3
Nia Hafey, Annville-Cleona: Honorable Mention – LL Section 4
Addison Hollenbach, Northern Lebanon: Honorable Mention – LL Section 4
Addison Kubica, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Morgan Long, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Lynsie Mauser, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Lydia McClintic, Cedar Crest: Honorable Mention
Addison Nolen, Cedar Crest: Honorable Mention
Abigail Palkovic, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Kate Poorman, Cedar Crest: Honorable Mention
Meda Pulaski, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Abby Ruth, ELCO: Honorable Mention – LL Section 3
Danika Setlock, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Jenna Seyfert, Lebanon: Honorable Mention – LL Section 2
Ashlyn Shaak, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Chloe Shirk, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Olivia Shutter, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Gabby Smith, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Karly Tice, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Riley Westenberger, Palmyra: 3rd Team – Mid Penn Keystone Division
Seira Wolfe, Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 2
Sereniti Zidik, Lebanon: Honorable Mention – LL Section 2
Honors by Tier
First Team
Brooke Beamesderfer, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Temperence Brubaker, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Kenzie Deeks, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Addison Kubica, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Morgan Long, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Lynsie Mauser, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Abigail Palkovic, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Meda Pulaski, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Danika Setlock, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Ashlyn Shaak, Annville-Cleona: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Chloe Shirk, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Gabby Smith, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Karly Tice, ELCO: 1st Team – LL Section 3
Olivia Shutter, Northern Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 4
Seira Wolfe, Lebanon: 1st Team – LL Section 2
Third Team / Honorable Mention
Anna Crawford, Palmyra: 3rd Team – Mid Penn Keystone Division
Abby Hassler, ELCO: Honorable Mention – LL Section 3
Nia Hafey, Annville-Cleona: Honorable Mention – LL Section 4
Addison Hollenbach, Northern Lebanon: Honorable Mention – LL Section 4
Lydia McClintic, Cedar Crest: Honorable Mention
Addison Nolen, Cedar Crest: Honorable Mention
Kate Poorman, Cedar Crest: Honorable Mention
Abby Ruth, ELCO: Honorable Mention – LL Section 3
Jenna Seyfert, Lebanon: Honorable Mention – LL Section 2
Riley Westenberger, Palmyra: 3rd Team – Mid Penn Keystone Division
Sereniti Zidik, Lebanon: Honorable Mention – LL Section 2
Honors by School
Annville-Cleona Dutchmen
Lancaster-Lebanon League Section 4
Temperence Brubaker (Fr.) – 1st Team
Nia Hafey ( Fr.) – Honorable Mention
Morgan Long (Jr.) – 1st Team
Meda Pulaski ( Sr.) – 1st Team
Danika Setlock ( Jr.) – 1st Team
Ashlyn Shaak (Sr.) – 1st Team
Cedar Crest Falcons
Lancaster-Lebanon League Section 1
Lydia McClintic ( Jr.) – Honorable Mention
Addison Nolen (So.) – Honorable Mention
Kate Poorman (Jr.) – Honorable Mention
ELCO Raiders
Lancaster-Lebanon League Section 3
Kenzie Deeks (So.) – 1st Team
Abby Hassler (Jr.) – Honorable Mention
Abby Ruth (So.) – Honorable Mention
Chloe Shirk (So.) – 1st Team
Gabby Smith (Jr.) – 1st Team
Karly Tice (Sr.) – 1st Team
Lebanon Cedars
Lancaster-Lebanon League Section 2
Jenna Seyfert (Jr.) – Honorable Mention
Seira Wolfe ( Sr.) – 1st Team
Sereniti Zidik (Jr.) – Honorable Mention
Northern Lebanon Vikings
Lancaster-Lebanon League Section 4
Brooke Beamesderfer ( Sr.) – 1st Team
Addison Hollenbach (So.) – Honorable Mention
Addison Kubica ( So.) – 1st Team
Lynsie Mauser (Jr.) – 1st Team
Abigail Palkovic ( Sr.) – 1st Team
Olivia Shutter (Jr.) – 1st Team
Palmyra Cougars
Mid Penn Conference – Keystone Division
Anna Crawford (Fr.) – 3rd Team
Riley Westenberger (Jr.) – 3rd Team
Middle Creek Roofing
Buzgon Davis Law Offices
TJT Sports
Kind Hearted Pet Resort
ProSeal
Penn Realty
Ask4Noah.com
