If you like this type of coverage, please let us know by Following us on social media: Twitter/X – @lebcosports1 and Facebook.
For any questions, comments, or discrepancies, please reach out to dan@lebcosports.com.
By Robert Griffiths
Should a Football Coach Be Feared or Loved by Their Players?
For those familiar with the book The Prince, by Machiavelli, you believe it is always safer to be feared than loved.
When applied to coaching, the question translates into enforcing tough discipline and no-excuses accountability. When I began coaching HS football in the 70s, my head coach gave me this advice: “You’re not here to be a friend to these youngsters. They have friends. You’re their coach. Teach them the discipline it takes to win.” Time has taught me that the formula for coaching success today is more complicated. Although, that doesn’t mean the advice isn’t valid.
When it comes to tough head coaches, the best example is Paul “Bear” Bryant, known best as the coach at Alabama. Before coaching at his alma mater, he coached at Texas A&M.
During his 4 years at Texas A&M, he earned a notorious reputation. He decided to begin summer practice isolated from the distractions of college life and the scrutiny of the administration. He relocated his team to the small Texas town of Junction. He practiced his team relentlessly in 100+ degree heat. He started with 100 soft, undisciplined players and ended up with 35 survivors. There’s a movie about this notorious camp called The Junction Boys.
Certainly, Bear Bryant is not the only football coach known as a feared taskmaster. Nick Saban’s “The Process” philosophy won 7 national championships, stressing unyielding perfectionism. Included on this list would be Woody Hayes, the old-school disciplinarian at Ohio State who won 5 national championships.
The NFL has also had its share of head coaches known for their “winning is the only thing” approach. The list includes Bill Belichick and Vince Lombardi. After retirement, many of their players expressed respect and admiration toward these tough coaches. Although, they made these statements at a safe distance from the sweat and blood of the practice field.
There are also successful head football coaches known for building strong personal relationships and understanding a player’s perspective rather than depending on discipline or fear. This coaching approach is referred to as being a “player’s coach.”
This list includes Pete Carroll (Seattle Seahawks, USC), who was like a father figure in handling star personalities. Others on this list of successful “player’s coaches” would be John Madden and Dick Vermeil.
Back to the original question: Is it best for a head football coach to be feared or loved? There are successful and unsuccessful coaches on both sides. If there is any lesson here for football coaches, it would be: Don’t try to be something you’re not.
If you’re a player’s coach, be that. If you’re a no-nonsense coach, be that. If you see yourself as a balance between the two extremes, go with it. But if you try to be something you’re not, your players will quickly figure you out, and when that happens, you have lost the game before your team takes the field.



