If you like this type of coverage, please let us know by Following us on social media: Twitter/X – @lebcosports1 and Facebook.
For any questions, comments, or discrepancies, please reach out to dan@lebcosports.com.
Written by Pete Steelman
Fink’s Overtime Winner Sends Palmyra Back to PIAA State Championship
For the Palmyra Cougars field hockey team, mid-November hockey games are nothing new. Cold weeknight games and frosty Saturday morning affairs have been the norm for the past several years, as the Cougars (23-1) perennially play into the deeper rounds of the State playoffs.
In Saturday’s thrilling nail-biter, where 60 minutes of regulation and two overtimes still couldn’t determine the victor against Keystone rival Red Land, their dramatic shootout win propelled them into the State semifinals Tuesday against District 1’s Bishop Shanahan.
While the nerves and drama of the Red Land win would have been tough to top, Tuesday’s game was every bit as nerve-wracking and closely contested. In the end, it was the top-seeded Cougars pulling out a thrilling 1-0 overtime victory, securing their second straight trip to the PIAA State Championship game.
The first quarter, although scoreless, was dominated by Palmyra. The Cougars were able to secure 5 penalty corners in the opening period, though a tight Bishop Shanahan defensive unit turned away every opportunity.
Perhaps the Cougars’ best chance to score came on their third corner attempt, when the insert was taken by junior Addie Barger, who was slide-tackled by the defensive flyer, taking her out at the knees and drawing the call of a penalty stroke.
After an officials’ meeting, the dangerous play was deemed unintentional and the penalty stroke call was reversed, the first of several controversial reversed calls by an officiating crew that did not seem to be on the same page for much of the game.
The second quarter was a much more balanced affair, as Palmyra saw fewer scoring opportunities, and the physical and aggressive play by Shanahan disrupted Palmyra’s rhythm.
Four penalty cards were assessed in the first half, as the Eagles’ aggression sometimes crossed the line, and to their credit, the Cougars did not back down from the physicality. As the game entered halftime, despite Shanahan not registering a single shot or penalty corner, the score remained knotted at 0-0.
The third period was more of the same, with aggressive pressure by Shanahan, as the Cougars’ defensive backfield showed considerable poise in not panicking while being constantly subjected to double teams.
In a game with so little room for error, one misplayed ball deep in their territory could have proved catastrophic. That said, the Cougar defenders and midfielders weathered the intense pressure, keeping the ball on the Eagles’ side of the field for the better part of the game.
As the scoreless game entered the 4th quarter, two close calls almost ended the season for Palmyra, and for the second game in a row, the Cougars had sophomore goalie Sophie Cunningham to thank.
The first scare came with 7:50 left in the game, when an Eagle run-out led to a 2-on-1 attack on the Palmyra goal. As the Eagle forward was preparing to unleash a shot, Cunningham charged out near the top of the circle, sliding at the dribbler’s stick and knocking the ball out of the circle to save a potential goal.
With 5:30 left, an almost identical situation played out again, when an aggressive Cunningham once again ventured far from the cage to take out the shooter and deny a prime scoring attempt.
Those two saves allowed Palmyra to breathe a sigh of relief, as time expired in regulation and once again their fate would be determined in overtime.
The 7-on-7 overtime period started precariously for Palmyra. The Cougars were already without the services of hobbled 10th grader Amelia Valle for much of the 2nd half, and one minute into overtime, senior captain Leigha Kane took an aggressive body check from an Eagle player, forcing her to leave the game while they tended to a bloody nose.
Already on their heels, Palmyra surrendered a penalty corner with 5:30 left in the first overtime, the Eagles’ first penalty corner of the entire game. After the insert and several passes, a backhand shot sailed wide right of the cage, giving possession back to the Cougars.
One minute later, after a scrum in Palmyra’s circle, another penalty corner was awarded to Bishop Shanahan, and Palmyra Nation couldn’t help but feel a sense of dread at yielding another scoring opportunity.
Yet while the lead official had called the infraction, the trail official near midfield had whistled an infraction against the Eagles. After a lengthy conference between the officials, another crucial call was overturned, this one benefiting the Cougars as the penalty corner was rescinded despite the irate protests from the Shanahan bench.
That call proved to be pivotal, as the Cougars almost immediately advanced the ball up the right sideline, where senior captain Maddy Waldron knifed her way toward the circle, sending the ball into the circle.
A shot by Allie Fink was deflected by the goalie, and it was Waldron with a touch pass back to Fink, who chipped in the game-winner as her teammates stormed the field in elation.
And with that, having already won the District Championship, Palmyra’s final and most lofty goal is now just one game away.
The Cougars will be playing for the State Championship Saturday against a familiar foe: the Warwick Warriors. Palmyra and Warwick have had a well-documented rivalry over the last 4 years, but lately it has been a story of Cougar domination.
Last year, Palmyra beat Warwick in both the District final and the State Championship game. And of course, just 3 weeks ago, the Cougars upended Warwick in winning their second straight District Championship.
It only seems appropriate that these two legacy programs, which have been the class of District 3 and all of the PIAA for the last few years, meet once again on Saturday with gold on the line.
Here is the 2A bracket.
Palmyra 1, Bishop Shanahan 0 (OT)
November 17, 2026 • Governor Mifflin High School • PIAA Class 2A Semifinal
| Team | 1Q | 2Q | 3Q | 4Q | OT | Final |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bishop Shanahan | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Palmyra | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Scoring Summary
Overtime
– 3:05 – Palmyra: Allie Fink, field goal (Maddy Waldron assist)
Team Statistics
| Statistic | Palmyra | Bishop Shanahan |
|---|---|---|
| Shots on Goal | 2 | 2 |
| Penalty Corners | 9 | 2 |
| Defensive Saves | 0 | 0 |
| Goalkeeper Saves | 2 | 1 |
Saves: Palmyra – Sophie Kennelly 0, Sophie Cunningham 2; Bishop Shanahan – Aly Civerra 1.




